Reviewed article

Hybrid Warfare Revisited: A Battle of ‘Buzzwords’

Connections vol. 22, no. 1, Winter 2023 (cover)

Connections vol. 22, no. 1, Winter 2023 Twenty Years of Substantive Impacts on Security and Defense Discourse

22.1.02_hybrid_warfare_f2.pdf

Abstract:

Hybrid warfare is the most common term used by commentators to describe the complexity and multifaceted character of contemporary warfare. Hybrid warfare refers to coercive methods of strategic competition that take place below the threshold of conventional military conflict and is usually applied to the blend of military and non-military methods of warfare employed by the West’s principal adversaries, Russia and China. The term hybrid warfare has evolved from an essentially military concept to one that potentially embraces all the instruments of state power. Hybrid warfare remains an ill-defined and contested term, and there are many other buzzwords, such as irregular warfare, hybrid threats, and gray zone aggression, that are used to describe the same phenomenon. This article examines the evolution of thinking on hybrid warfare and these related concepts. It highlights the challenges that scholars and practitioners have faced in trying to define and apply these terms in the policy environment in a manner that promotes common understanding and strategic coherence.

Article statistics

Wither, James K. 2023. “Hybrid Warfare Revisited: A Battle of ‘Buzzwords’”. Connections: The Quarterly Journal 22 (1): 7-28. doi:https://doi.org/10.11610/Connections.22.1.02.

4306 Views

Bibliography

James K. Wither, “Making Sense of Hybrid Warfare,” Connections: The Quarterly Journal 15, no. 2 (2016): 73-87, http://dx.doi.org/10.11610/Connections.15.2.06

Ben Hodges, “Lt-Gen Ben Hodges on the Future of Hybrid Warfare,” CEPA, April 8, 2021, accessed October 24, 2022, https://cepa.org/article/lt-gen-ben-hodges-on-the-future-of-hybrid-warfare/

Colin S. Gray, Modern Strategy (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999), 159.

Colin S. Gray, Another Bloody Century: Future Warfare (London: Orion Books, 2006), 199.

Frank G. Hoffman, Conflict in the 21st Century: The Rise of Hybrid Wars (Arlington, VA: Potomac Institute for Policy Studies, December 2007), 8, https://www.potomacinstitute.org/images/stories/publications/potomac_hybridwar_0108.pdf

Peter R. Mansoor, “Hybrid War in History,” in Hybrid Warfare: Fighting Complex Opponents from the Ancient World to the Present, ed. Williamson Murray and Peter R. Mansoor (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2012).

Loretta Sanchez, Jeff Miller, and Adam Smith, “Hybrid Warfare,” GAO-10-1036R (Washington, DC: United States Government Accountability Office, September 2010), accessed October 24, 2022, https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-10-1036r

Qiao Liang and Wang Xiangsui, Unrestricted Warfare (Beijing: PLA Literature and Arts Pub¬lishing House, February 1999), accessed November 5, 2022, https://www.oodaloop.com/documents/unrestricted.pdf

Hew Strachan, The Direction of War: Contemporary Strategy in Historical Perspective (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, December 2013), 82.

Tim Benbow, “Talking ‘Bout Our Generation? Assessing the Concept of Fourth Generation Warfare,” Comparative Strategy 27, no. 2 (2008): 148-163, https://doi.org/10.1080/01495930801944685

Interview by Octavian Manea with Dr. Mark Galeotti, “Hybrid War as a War on Governance,” Small Wars Journal, August 19, 2015, accessed October 24, 2022, https://smallwarsjournal.com/jrnl/art/hybrid-war-as-a-war-on-governance

Sun Tzu, The Art of War, Translated by Samuel B. Griffith (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1971), 41, 77.

Geraint Hughes, “Little Green Men and Red Armies: Why Russian ‘Hybrid War’ Is Nothing New,” Research Blog, Defence in Depth, King’s College London, March 14, 2016, https://defenceindepth.co/2016/03/14/little-green-men-and-red-armies-why-russian-hybrid-war-is-not-new/

Bettina Renz, “Russia and ‘Hybrid Warfare’,” Comparative Politics 22, no. 3 (2016): 283-300, https://doi.org/10.1080/13569775.2016.1201316

Michael Kofman et al., “Lessons from Russia’s Operations in Crimea and Eastern Ukraine,” Research Report RR-1498-A (Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation, 2017), xi, accessed October 20, 2022, https://doi.org/10.7249/RR1498

e – The Emergence of Hybrid Warfare,” ISPSW Strategy Series, May 2015, accessed October 20, 2022, www.files.ethz.ch/isn/190792/347_Thiele_RINSA.pdf.

Stephen Blank, “Russia, Hybrid War and the Evolution of Europe,” Second Line of Defense, February 14, 2015, https://sldinfo.com/2015/02/russia-hybrid-war-and-the-evolution-of-europe/

Michael Kofman and Matthew Rojansky, “A Closer Look at Russia’s ‘Hybrid War’,” Kennan Cable, no. 7 (Wilson Center, April 2015), 5, https://www.wilsoncenter.org/publication/kennan-cable-no7-closer-look-russias-hybrid-war

“Editor’s Introduction: Complex Crises Call for Adaptable and Durable Capabilities,” The Military Balance 115, no. 1 (2015), 5, https://doi.org/10.1080/04597222.2015.996334

Frank G. Hoffman, “Examining Complex Forms of Conflict: Gray Zone and Hybrid Challenges,” PRISM 7, no. 4 (2018), 40, https://cco.ndu.edu/Portals/96/Documents/prism/prism7_4/181204_Hoffman_PDF.pdf

Valery Gerasimov, “The Value of Science in Prediction,” Military-Industrial Kurier, Feb¬ruary 27, 2013, available in English in Mark Galeotti, “The Gerasimov Doctrine and Russian Non-Linear War,” In Moscow’s Shadows Blog, July 6, 2014, accessed October 24, 2022, https://inmoscowsshadows.wordpress.com/2014/07/06/the-gerasimov-doctrine-and-russian-non-linear-war/

S.G. Chekinov and Lt. Gen. S.A. Bogdanov, “The Nature and Content of a New-Generation War,” Voyennaya Mysl’ (Military Thought), no. 10 (2013), 13, h ttps://www.usni.org/sites/default/files/inline-files/Chekinov-Bogdanov%20Miltary%20Thought%202013.pdf

Ofer Fridman, “Hybrid Warfare or Gibridnaya Voyna? Similar, But Different,” The RUSI Journal 162, no. 1 (2017): 42-49, https://doi.org/10.1080/03071847.2016.1253370

Mason Clark, “Russian Hybrid Warfare,” Military Learning and the Future of War Series (Washington, DC: Institute for the Study of War, September 2020), 16-17, https://www.understandingwar.org/report/russian-hybrid-warfare

Keir Giles, “‘Hybrid Warfare’ and Russia’s Ground Forces,” NIDS International Symposium “A New Strategic Environment and Roles of Ground Forces,” January 30, 2019, pp. 79-92, http://www.nids.mod.go.jp/english/event/international_symposium/pdf/2018/e-05.pdf

Michael Kofman et al., “Russian Military Strategy: Core Tenets and Operational Concepts,” Center for Naval Analyses, October 2021, 27, accessed November 21, 2022, www.cna.org/reports/2021/10/russian-military-strategy-core-tenets-and-concepts

Roger N. McDermott and Charles K. Bartles, “Defining the ‘Special Military Operation’,” Article Review, Russian Studies Series, 5/22, NATO Defense College, accessed October 25, 2022, https://www.ndc.nato.int/research/research.php?icode=777

Mark Galeotti, “(Mis)Understanding Russia’s ‘Two Hybrid Wars’,” Eurozine, November 29, 2018, accessed October 25, 2022, https://www.eurozine.com/misunderstanding-russias-two-hybrid-wars/

Mikael Weissmann, “Hybrid Warfare and Hybrid Threats Today and Tomorrow: Towards an Analytical Framework,” Journal on Baltic Security 5, no. 1 (2019): 17-26, ht tps://journalonbalticsecurity.com/journal/JOBS/article/40/info

Niklas Nilsson et al., “Security Challenges in the Gray Zone: Hybrid Threats and Hybrid Warfare,” in Hybrid Warfare: Security and Asymmetric Conflict in International Relations, Bloomsbury Collections, ed. Mikael Weissmann, Niklas Nilsson, Björn Palmertz, and Per Thunholm (London: Bloomsbury Publishing, 2021).

Sean Monaghan, “Countering Hybrid Warfare Project,” Information Note, MCDC Countering Hybrid Warfare Project, March 2019, 3, https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/840513/20190401-MCDC_CHW_Information_note_-_Conceptual_Foundations.pdf

Elisabeth Braw, The Defender’s Dilemma: Identifying and Deterring Gray-Zone Aggression (Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute, March 2022), 9.

NATO, “NATO 2030: United for a New Era,” Analysis and Recommedations of the Reflection Group Appointed by the NATO Secretary General, November 25, 2020, 45-46, accessed November 8, 2022, https://www.nato.int/nato_static_fl2014/assets/pdf/2020/12/pdf/201201-Reflection-Group-Final-Report-Uni.pdf

Quoted in “NATO’s Response to Hybrid Threats,” NATO, accessed November 4, 2022, https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/topics_156338.htm

European Commission / Hybrid COE, Landscape of Hybrid Threats: A Conceptual Model (Luxembourg: Publications Office of the EU, 2021), 10, accessed November 6, 2022, https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/b534e5b3-7268-11eb-9ac9-1aa75ed71a1

Dick Zandee, Sico van der Meer, and Adája Stoetman, “Hybrid Threats: Searching for a Definition,” in Counterig Hybrid Threats: Steps for Improving EU-NATO Cooperation, Clingendael Report (The Hague, The Netherlands: The Clingendael Institute, October 2021), pp. 6-29, https://www.clingendael.org/pub/2021/countering-hybrid-threats/2-hybrid-threats-searching-for-a-definition/

John Raine, “War or Peace? Understanding the Grey Zone,” IISS, April 3, 2019, accessed November 9, 2022, https://www.iiss.org/blogs/analysis/2019/04/understanding-the-grey-zone

Zandee, van der Meer, and Stoetman, “Hybrid Threats: Searching for a Definition,” 9; and Ewan Lawson, “We Need to Talk About Hybrid,” The RUSI Journal 166, no. 3 (2021): 58-66, 59-61, https://doi.org/10.1080/03071847.2021.1950330

“NATO 2022 Strategic Concept” (NATO, June 2022), 3, accessed November 4, 2022, https://www.nato.int/strategic-concept/index.html

David H. Ucko and Thomas A. Marks, Crafting Strategy for Irregular Warfare: A Framework for Analysis and Action, Strategic Monograph, 2nd edition (Washington, D.C.: National Defense University Press, September 2022) https://ndupress.ndu.edu/Media/News/News-Article-View/Article/3163915/crafting-strategy-for-irregular-warfare-a-framework-for-analysis-and-action-2nd/

Seth G. Jones, “The Future of Competition: U.S. Adversaries and the Growth of Irregular Warfare,” CSIS, February 4, 2021, accessed November 7, 2022, https://www.csis.org/analysis/future-competition-us-adversaries-and-growth-irregular-warfare

Antulio J. Echevarria, Operating in the Gray Zone: An Alternative Paradigm for U.S. Military Strategy (Carlisle, PA: US Army War College Press, April 2016), 1, https://press.armywarcollege.edu/monographs/425/

U.S. Joint Staff, “Curriculum Development Guide for Irregular Warfare,” Office of Irregular Warfare and Competition, Directorate for Joint Force Development (J-7), June 3, 2022, 7.

U.S. Department of Defense, “Irregular Warfare: Countering Irregular Threats,” Joint Operating Concept, Version 2, May 17, 2010, 9, accessed November 7, 2021, https://www.jcs.mil/Portals/36/Documents/Doctrine/concepts/joc_iw_v2.pdf?ver=2017-12-28-162021-510

U.S. Department of Defense, “Summary of the Irregular Warfare Annex to the National Defense Strategy,” 2020, 2, https://media.defense.gov/2020/Oct/02/2002510472/-1/-1/0/Irregular-Warfare-Annex-to-the-National-Defense-Strategy-Summary.PDF

David H. Ucko and Thomas A. Marks, “Redefining Irregular Warfare: Legitimacy, Coercion, and Power,” Modern War Institute, October 18, 2022, accessed November 8, 2022, ht tps://mwi.usma.edu/redefining-irregular-warfare-legitimacy-coercion-and-power/

Jeremiah C. Lumbaca, “Irregular Competition: Conceptualizing a Whole-of-Government Approach for the United States to Indirectly Confront and Deter State and Nonstate Adversaries,” Military Review (July-August 2022), accessed November 15, 2022, https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/July-August-2022/Lumbaca/

Robert M. Gates, “The Overmilitarization of American Foreign Pol¬icy: The United States Must Recover the Full Range of Its Power,” Foreign Affairs (July/ August 2020), https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2020-06-02/robert-gates-overmilitarization-american-foreign-policy

U.S. Department of Defense, “National Defense Strategy of the United States of America,” 2022, 6, https://www.defense.gov/National-Defense-Strategy/

Melissa Dalton et al., “By Other Means – Part 2: U.S. Priorities in the Gray Zone,” A Report of the CSIS International Security Program (Center for Strategic and International Studies/ Rowman & Littlefield, August 2019), 2, https://defense360.csis.org/by-other-means-part-ii-u-s-priorities-in-the-gray-zone/

Michael J. Mazarr, Mastering the Gray Zone: Understanding a Changing Era of Conflict (Carlisle, PA: USAWC Press, 2015), 44-46, accessed November 10, 2021, https://press.armywarcollege.edu/monographs/428/

BBC Monitoring, “China’s Public Diplomacy on Twitter and Facebook,” 2021, 8, https://www.academia.edu/80483985/Chinas_public_diplomacy_on_Twitter_and_Facebook

“Return of Global Russia,” Speech by Senator Mark Warner to the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, March 1, 2018, accessed November 11, 2022, https://www.warner.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/blog?ID=F2851C9D-3E4A-4F85-A54E-92F1B747360C

Stacie L. Pettyjohn and Becca Wasser, “Competing in the Gray Zone: Russian Tactics and Western Responses,” Research Report RR-2791-A (RAND Corporation, 2019), Chapter 4, https://doi.org/10.7249/RR2791

Doug Livermore, “China’s Three Warfares in Theory and Practice in the South China Sea,” Georgetown Security Studies Review, March 25, 2018, https://georgetownsecuritystudiesreview.org/2018/03/25/chinas-three-warfares-in-theory-and-practice-in-the-south-china-sea/

David Knoll, Kevin Pollpeter, and Sam Plap¬inger, “China’s Irregular Approach to Warfare: The Myth of a Purely Conventional Fight,” Modern War Institute, April 27, 2021, accessed November 15, 2022, https://mwi.usma.edu/chinas-irregular-approach-to-war-the-myth-of-a-purely-conventional-future-fight/

Eric Levitz, “Biden’s New Cold War Against China Could Backfire,” Intelligencer, November 14, 2022, https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2022/11/biden-economic-war-china-chips-semiconductors-export-controls.html

Bonnie Glaser, “How China Uses Economic Coercion to Silence Critics and Achieve Its Political Aims Globally,” Testimony before the Congressional Executive Commission on China, December 7, 2021, accessed November 14, 2022, https://www.cecc.gov/events/hearings/how-china-uses-economic-coercion-to-silence-critics-and-achieve-its-political-aims

Ashley Townshend and Thomas Lonergan, “Australia Must Adopt Unorthodox Options to Disrupt China’s Grey-Zone Threats,” The Guardian, September 28, 2021, accessed November 13, 2022, https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/commentisfree/2021/sep/28/australia-must-adopt-unorthodox-options-to-disrupt-chinas-grey-zone-threats

Hoffman, “Examining Complex Forms of Conflict,” 36; and David Barno and Nora Bensahel, “Fighting and Winning in the ‘Gray Zone’,” War on the Rocks, May 19, 2015, accessed November 10, 2022, https://warontherocks.com/2015/05/fighting-and-winning-in-the-gray-zone/

Michael Eisenstadt, “Iran’s Gray Zone Strategy: Cornerstone of Its Asymmetrical Way of War,” PRISM 9, no. 2 (2021): 77-97, 78, accessed November 10, 2022, https://ndupress.ndu.edu/Journals/PRISM/PRISM-9-2/

Geraint Hughes, My Enemy’s Enemy: Proxy Warfare in International Politics (Eastbourne: Sussex Academic Press, 2012), 2.

Mark Galeotti, The Weaponisation of Everything: A Field Guide to the New Way of War (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2022), 18.

Arsalan Bilal, “Hybrid Warfare – New Threats, Complexities and ‘Trust’ as the Antidote,” NATO Review, November 30, 2021, accessed October 24, 2022, https://www.nato.int/docu/review/articles/2021/11/30/hybrid-warfare-new-threats-complexity-and-trust-as-the-antidote/index.html

Raphael S. Cohen et al., “The Future of Warfare in 2030: Project Overview and Conclusions,” Research Report RR-2849/1-AF (Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation, 2020), 13-14, accessed November 15, 2022, https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR2849z1.html

George Kennan, “Policy Planning Staff Memorandum,” May 1948, accessed November 15, 2022, http://academic.brooklyn.cuny.edu/history/johnson/65ciafounding3.htm

Kevin Bilms, “Gray Is Here to Stay: Principles from the Interim National Security Strategic Guidance on Competing in the Gray Zone,” Modern War Institute, March 25, 2021, accessed November 9, 2022, https://mwi.usma.edu/gray-is-here-to-stay-principles-from-the-interim-national-security-strategic-guidance-on-competing-in-the-gray-zone/

Richard Haass, “The Dangerous Decade: A Foreign Policy for a World in Crisis,” Foreign Affairs (September/October 2022), https://www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/dangerous-decade-foreign-policy-world-crisis-richard-haass

Scott Jasper, “Can Russian Hybrid Warfare Win the Day in Ukraine?” The National Interest, October 7, 2022, accessed November 19, 2022, https://nationalinterest.org/blog/techland-when-great-power-competition-meets-digital-world/can-russian-hybrid-warfare-win-day

Manoj Joshi, “The Russia-Ukraine War: Ukraine’s Resistance in the Face of Hybrid Warfare,” Observer Research Foundation, June 6, 2022, accessed November 2, 2022, https://www.orfonline.org/expert-speak/ukraines-resistance-in-the-face-of-hybrid-warfare/

Andrea Kendall-Taylor and Michael Kofman, “Russia’s Dangerous Decline: The Kremlin Won’t Go Down Without a Fight,” Foreign Affairs (November/December 2022), https://www.foreignaffairs.com/ukraine/russia-dangerous-decline

“A New Age of Economic Conflict,” The Economist, March 2, 2022, https://www.economist.com/leaders/a-new-age-of-economic-conflict/21807968

Cameron Jenkins, “Kremlin Official Says West Has Declared ‘Total War’ on Russia,” The Hill, March 25, 2022, accessed November 16, 2022, https://thehill.com/policy/international/russia/599722-lavrov-says-west-has-declared-total-war-on-russia/

Peter Clement, “Putin’s Risk Spiral: The Logic of Escalation in an Unraveling War,” Foreign Affairs, October 26, 2022, https://www.foreignaffairs.com/ukraine/putin-risk-spiral-logic-of-escalation-in-war

Melissa Eddy, “Pipeline Breaks Look Deliberate, Europeans Say, Exposing Vulnerability,” The New York Times, September 28, 2022, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/27/world/europe/pipeline-leak-russia-nord-stream.html

Richard Milne, “Damaged Baltic Sea Pipelines Put Western Powers on Alert for Sabotage,” Financial Times, September 29, 2022.

Marcus Willett, “The Cyber Dimension of the Russia-Ukraine War,” Survival 64, no. 5 (October-November 2022): 7-26, quote on p. 21, https://doi.org/10.1080/00396338.2022.2126193

Simon Tisdall, “Unseen and Underhand: Putin’s Hidden Hybrid War Is Trying to Break Europe’s Heart,” The Observer, October 23, 2022, https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/oct/23/unseen-and-underhand-putins-hidden-hybrid-war-is-trying-to-break-europes-heart

Eliot A. Cohen, “America’s Hesitation Is Heartbreaking,” The Atlantic, March 14, 2022, www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/03/ukraine-united-states-nato/627052/.

Sam Winter-Levy, “A Proxy War in Ukraine Is the Worst Possible Outcome – Except for All the Others,” War on the Rocks, March 28, 2022, accessed November 21, 2022, https://warontherocks.com/2022/03/a-proxy-war-in-ukraine-is-the-worst-possible-outcome-except-for-all-the-others/

Hals Brand, “Russia Is Right: The U.S. Is Waging a Proxy War in Ukraine,” The Washington Post, May 10, 2022, www.washingtonpost.com/business/russia-is-right-the-us-is-waging-aproxy-war-in-ukraine/2022/05/10/2c8058a4-d051-11ec-886b-df761….

Dov S. Zakheim, “Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine Has Sparked a Proxy World War,” The Hill, November 18, 2022, accessed November 21, 2022, https://thehill.com/opinion/national-security/3739744-russias-invasion-of-ukraine-has-sparked-a-proxy-world-war/

U.S. Department of Defense, “Secretary of Defense Lloyd J. Austin III Holds a News Conference Following Ukraine Defense Consultative Group Meeting, Ramstein Air Base, Germany,” Transcript, April 26, 2022, accessed November 21, 2022, https://www.defense.gov/News/Transcripts/Transcript/Article/3011263/secretary-of-defense-lloyd-j-austin-iii-holds-a-news-conference-following-ukrai/

Liana Fix and Michael Kimmage, “What If the War in Ukraine Spins Out of Control? How to Prepare for Unintended Escalation,” Foreign Affairs, July 19, 2022, https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/ukraine/2022-07-18/what-if-war-in-ukraine-spins-out-control